LNG: Benefits and Risks of Liquified Natural Gas

For decades, natural gas has been used to provide clean power to thousands of households and businesses nationwide. Today, more than 1,000 vehicles traveling U.S. roads are powered by natural gas that is cooled to a liquid—liquefied natural gas (LNG). LNG results when natural gas is cooled to temperatures of 260 degrees below zero, thus producing a viable vehicle fuel used mainly in heavy-duty trucks and buses.

About LNG

LNG is odorless, colorless, noncorrosive, and nontoxic. When extracted from underground reserves, natural gas is composed of approximately 90 percent methane. During the liquefaction process, oxygen, carbon dioxide, sulfur compounds, and water are removed, purifying the fuel and increasing its methane content to almost 100 percent. As a result, LNG-fueled vehicles can offer significant emissions compared with older diesel-powered vehicles, and can significantly reduce carbon monoxide and particulate emissions as well as nitrogen oxide emissions.

LNG Emissions

Actual emissions will vary with engine design; these numbers reflect the potential reductions offered by LNG relative to diesel.

  • Production of half particulate matter of average diesel vehicles.
  • Can significantly reduce carbon monoxide emissions.
  • Reductions of nitrogen oxide and volatile organic hydrocarbon emissions by 50 percent or more.
  • Potential reductions in carbon dioxide emissions of 25 percent depending on the source of the natural gas.
  • Drastic reductions in toxic and carcinogenic pollutants.
  • Increase in methane emissions.

LNG Availability

To date, LNG vehicles have primarily been used by fleet managers. Therefore, most LNG refueling stations are located at heavy-duty vehicle fleet operations not open to the public. This is due in part to the various safety issues discussed later. In conjunction with plans to expand LNG use in long-haul trucking in the West, efforts are under way to improve access to LNG fueling stations in that region. For example, California expects to fund the development of public-access facilities. Such a program is aimed at helping heavyduty trucks switch to natural gas.

LNG's complex onboard storage system does not make it a viable fuel for light-duty vehicles. It is, however, replacing diesel in many heavy-duty trucks and buses and many new gas-fueled locomotives. For example, some trash trucks in San Diego and some long-haul trucks in Los Angeles and Sacramento use LNG fuel. In addition, the number of LNG-fueled transit buses is expanding rapidly as many cities try to reduce pollution levels. Bus fleets in Orange County, California, and Phoenix, Arizona, are fueled entirely by LNG.

LNG Affordability

Depending on the quantity of vehicles purchased and the equipment used, LNG heavy-duty trucks or buses can an additional $30,000 to $50,000. Industry experts expect these costs to drop as market development and vehicle production rises. Fuel dispensing and fuel storage required for LNG typically costs $15,000 to $22,000 per vehicle. In addition, LNG's price is highly dependent on geographic location, purity of feedstock, transportation costs, and quantity of fuel purchased, but LNG's cost per mile is generally less than or equal to the price of diesel.

LNG Performance

There are no discernible differences in LNG vehicle performance, operation, and utility when compared with diesel. The high ignition quality of LNG is similar to that of diesel, providing for similar durability and engine life overall.

LNG Safety

A LNG vehicle parked indoors and unmoved for a week or more will vent a flammable gas mixture that could catch fire in the vicinity of an ignition source. To address this safety issue, LNG use should be restricted to frequently driven fleet vehicles or to vehicles stored outdoors. Only trained personnel should service the vehicles.

Additionally, refueling vehicles with LNG requires training because of the fuel's ultra-low temperature. It can cause frostbite if it contacts skin. Since LNG is almost 100 percent methane—a greenhouse gas—it can also contribute to global climate change if accidentally released into the air. Methane is slightly soluble in water and, under certain (anaerobic), it does not bio-degrade. If excess amounts accumulate, the gas can bubble from the water, possibly creating a of fire or explosion.

LNG Maintenance

LNG's cleaner burning characteristics can result in longer engine life and reduced maintenance costs. Using LNG eliminates the need for periodic tank inspections. In addition, some maintenance savings are anticipated for vehicles using LNG when compared with gasoline-powered vehicles because of the reduced frequency of oil changes. Because of the fuel's below freezing temperatures, only trained personnel should maintain LNG vehicles.

LNG Success

In its quest to be an environmental leader, Waste Management, Inc., began using LNG in 1998 to fuel six of its waste haulers in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Since that time, driver response has been very positive, in part because LNG generates less noise than diesel-powered engines.

In California, the company is currently purchasing new vehicles and converting existing vehicle engines to run on LNG. Soon, more than 100 of the company's heavy-duty trucks will use both compressed and liquefied natural gas.

In addition to helping the environment, the company's use of LNG is benefiting its bottom line. By using cleaner fuels such as LNG, the company has a competitive advantage when bidding on waste hauling contracts in cities trying to control air emissions.